US Lacrosse Coaches Association · USA Lacrosse
Boys High School
All-Americans
All 17,650 boys honored from 1971 to 2026. Find a player, browse a season, or see everyone from your school or state.
NY
All seasons · All states · All schools
1,900 players
| Season | Player | Position | School | Region | State |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1971 | |||||
| 1971 | Andrew Gallina | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1971 | Robert Griebe | Attack | Deer Park HS | — | NY |
| 1971 | Charles Hayes | Defense | Hempstead High | — | NY |
| 1971 | James Hogan | Attack | Lindenhurst | Suffolk | NY |
| 1971 | Ron Kaznecha | Attack | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1971 | Tom Kryjak | Defense | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1971 | Ken Kubie | Attack | Scarsdale | — | NY |
| 1971 | Ralph McGee | Midfield | Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy | Nassau | NY |
| 1971 | Terry McNabb | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1971 | Richard Meister | Defense | Deer Park HS | — | NY |
| 1971 | Edward Mullen | Attack | St. Mary's School | — | NY |
| 1971 | William O Hara | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1971 | Jamie Slofosky | Goal | St. Mary's School | — | NY |
| 1971 | Richard Werner | Midfield | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1972 | |||||
| 1972 | O.J. Alexander | Attack | Smithtown | Suffolk | NY |
| 1972 | Steve Carroll | Attack | St. Mary's School | — | NY |
| 1972 | John Danowski | Attack | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1972 | Bob Desimone | Midfield | Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy | Nassau | NY |
| 1972 | Andy Ehrman | Goal | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1972 | Jerry Kress | Attack | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1972 | Jeff Long | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1972 | Billy Marino | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 1972 | Eamon McEneaney | Attack | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1972 | Steve Meinsen | Midfield | Harborfields High | — | NY |
| 1972 | Brooks Nelson | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1972 | Stuart Nelson | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1972 | Bill O Brien | Midfield | MacArthur | Nassau | NY |
| 1972 | Tom Rafferty | Defense | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1972 | Dennis Rogers | Attack | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1972 | Eric Snider | Midfield | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1972 | Mike Sweeney | Defense | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1972 | Bob Van Slyke | Goal | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1972 | Rory Whipple | Midfield | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1973 | |||||
| 1973 | Tom Abbott | Attack | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1973 | Chuck Apel | Defense | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1973 | Ralph Baugher | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1973 | Bill Duford | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1973 | Richard Hirch | Midfield | Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy | Nassau | NY |
| 1973 | Tom Leyden | Attack | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1973 | Jeff Long | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1973 | Francis McAleavey | Attack | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1973 | Eamon McEneaney | Attack | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1973 | Peter Rose | Midfield | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1974 | |||||
| 1974 | Terry Allen | Midfield | East Syracuse-Minoa | Central | NY |
| 1974 | Scott Baugher | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1974 | Mark Belli | Defense | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 1974 | Scott Findlay | Midfield | Nyack | — | NY |
| 1974 | Bob Hendrickson | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1974 | Craig Jaeger | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 1974 | Sandy Kapatos | Goal | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1974 | Kovar | Defense | Uniondale | Nassau | NY |
| 1974 | Richard Lewton | Defense | Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy | Nassau | NY |
| 1974 | Richerd Lundblad | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1974 | Fran McAleavy | Attack | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1974 | Ron Parisi | Goal | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 1974 | Kris Snider | Attack | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1974 | Joseph Speno | Attack | Watertown | Central | NY |
| 1975 | |||||
| 1975 | John Banner | Midfield | Tully | Central | NY |
| 1975 | Bob Boneillo | Attack | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1975 | Peter Bourne | Goal | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1975 | Mike Chanenchuk | Midfield | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1975 | Mark Davitt | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1975 | Mike Duffy | Attack | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 1975 | Bob Engelke | Attack | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1975 | Mike Farrell | Attack | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1975 | Joe Garavante | Midfield | Uniondale | Nassau | NY |
| 1975 | Steve Gramerosa | Defense | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1975 | Bob Jackson | Goal | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1975 | Jim Latini | Goal | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1975 | Tim OHara | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1975 | Ian Patterson | Defense | Trinity Pawling | New England Western | NY |
| 1975 | Ed Pray | Defense | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 1975 | Peter Predun | Midfield | Harborfields High | — | NY |
| 1975 | Bob Remilen | Midfield | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1975 | Greg Rumpf | Midfield | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1975 | Fran Shields | Attack | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 1976 | |||||
| 1976 | Bob Boneillo | Attack | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1976 | Morty Bouchard | Defense | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1976 | Mark Bristol | Goal | Rush-Henrietta | — | NY |
| 1976 | Michael Buzzell | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1976 | Jeff Cohen | Goal | Nyack | — | NY |
| 1976 | John Driscoll | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1976 | Bob Eisendorfer | Attack | Nyack | — | NY |
| 1976 | Mike Farrell | Attack | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1976 | Bill Fisher | Goal | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1976 | Ed Gambitski | Defense | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1976 | Mike Hathaway | Midfield | Mynderse Academy | — | NY |
| 1976 | Jim Howe | Midfield | Tully | Central | NY |
| 1976 | Peter Predun | Midfield | Harborfields High | — | NY |
| 1976 | Mark Sackerson | Attack | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 1976 | Tony Saverese | Defense | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1976 | Mike Scibelli | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1976 | Tom Sweeney | Attack | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1976 | Christopher Sweet | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1976 | Tony Vitrano | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 1976 | Jim Zaffuto | Attack | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1977 | |||||
| 1977 | Frank Ambrosio | Goal | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1977 | Robert Bero | Attack | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 1977 | Wade Bollinger | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1977 | Gary Burns | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1977 | Joe Castellanetta | Attack | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1977 | Steve Crowley | Midfield | Great Neck South | — | NY |
| 1977 | Ken Dahl | Midfield | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY |
| 1977 | Tom Donahue | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1977 | Howard Ebner | Midfield | Great Neck North | — | NY |
| 1977 | Norm Engelke | Midfield | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1977 | Tim Enright | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1977 | Charles Epes | Attack | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 1977 | Dave Guill | Midfield | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1977 | Ryland Huyghue | Midfield | Paul Schreiber | — | NY |
| 1977 | Klay Johnson | Midfield | Croton-Harmon | — | NY |
| 1977 | Mark Leszczynski | Midfield | Rush-Henrietta | — | NY |
| 1977 | Ed Menegaux | Defense | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1977 | Jim Metzger | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1977 | Ray Mulligan | Midfield | St. John the Baptist | Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1977 | Jeff Oliver | Midfield | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 1977 | Al Ray | Midfield | Copiague | — | NY |
| 1977 | Dave Sells | Goal | Oceanside | Nassau | NY |
| 1977 | Bill Sipperly | Midfield | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1977 | Jim Zaffuto | Attack | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1978 | |||||
| 1978 | Mark Albe | Midfield | Nyack | — | NY |
| 1978 | Bill Bauer | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1978 | Wade Bolinger | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1978 | Gary Burns | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1978 | Ken Dahl | Midfield | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY |
| 1978 | Chris Esmonde | Defense | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1978 | Greg French | Midfield | East Syracuse-Minoa | Central | NY |
| 1978 | Ray Guisto | Midfield | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1978 | Doug Hall | Attack | Levittown Memorial | Nassau | NY |
| 1978 | Rick Herrick | Attack | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 1978 | Dave Lerner | Goal | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1978 | Al Ray | Midfield | Copiague | — | NY |
| 1978 | Dough Rice | Attack | Nottingham | Central | NY |
| 1978 | Rich Rosino | Defense | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1978 | Mike Santimays | Attack | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1978 | Bob Sipperly | Attack | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1978 | Mike Smith | Midfield | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 1978 | Bob Staugaitis | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1978 | Guy Van Arsdale | Goal | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 1978 | Kevin Ward | Attack | Rush-Henrietta | — | NY |
| 1978 | Mark Wenham | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1978 | Bob Zimmerman | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1979 | |||||
| 1979 | Chris Anglim | Goal | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1979 | Mike Buttleman | Attack | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 1979 | Bill Cantelli | Attack | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1979 | Lou Delligatti | Midfield | Oceanside | Nassau | NY |
| 1979 | John Ednie | Defense | Hicksville | Nassau | NY |
| 1979 | Willie Evans | Defense | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1979 | Joshua Gully | Midfield | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 1979 | Brian Haggerty | Attack | Nyack | — | NY |
| 1979 | Cal Harris | Attack | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1979 | Robert Henry | Midfield | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 1979 | Scott Huff | Midfield | Smithtown | Suffolk | NY |
| 1979 | Red Hutson | Midfield | Tully | Central | NY |
| 1979 | Lambert Jimmerson | Defense | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 1979 | Randy Lundblad | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1979 | Mark Martino | Midfield | White Plains | — | NY |
| 1979 | Jeff McCormick | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1979 | Duane Nowicki | Attack | Lindenhurst | Suffolk | NY |
| 1979 | Jim Paris | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1979 | Mike Powers | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1979 | Jim Raggi | Midfield | Nyack | — | NY |
| 1979 | Richard Riccardi | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 1979 | Wayne Roemer | Defense | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1979 | Guy Vanarsdale | Goal | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 1980 | |||||
| 1980 | Chris Asterino | Midfield | East Syracuse-Minoa | Central | NY |
| 1980 | Angelo Campana | Attack | Gorton | Yonkers | NY |
| 1980 | Randy Cox | Defense | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 1980 | Paul Dinnage | Defense | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 1980 | Brian Edmonds | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1980 | Mike Fitzpatrick | Attack | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1980 | Bob Goettleman | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1980 | Dave Goodspeed | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1980 | Bill Hardy | Defense | Tully | Central | NY |
| 1980 | Mike Lapham | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1980 | Jeff Larue | Midfield | Webster Schroeder | Monroe County | NY |
| 1980 | Ken Lund | Defense | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1980 | Randy Lundblad | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1980 | Kevin Meinsen | Midfield | Harborfields High | — | NY |
| 1980 | Kurt Metzler | Defense | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1980 | Glen Muhrman | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 1980 | Bill Naslonski | Midfield | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1980 | E.J. Nicholas | Defense | North Rockland | — | NY |
| 1980 | Tom Nims | Goal | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1980 | John Patak | Defense | Mynderse Academy | — | NY |
| 1980 | Marty Redeye | Attack | Salamanca City Central | — | NY |
| 1981 | |||||
| 1981 | Dennis Bucklet | Midfield | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1981 | Pat Dugan | Midfield | North Rockland | — | NY |
| 1981 | Steve Hake | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 1981 | Eric Jeschke | Midfield | Henninger High | Central | NY |
| 1981 | John Krumenacker | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1981 | Glenn Lay | Midfield | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 1981 | Dave Mooney | Goal | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1981 | Jeff Nicklas | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 1981 | Emmitt Printup | Attack | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 1981 | Larry Quinn | Goal | Levittown Memorial | Nassau | NY |
| 1981 | Wayne Reed | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1981 | Joe Savarese | Attack | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1981 | John Scorcia | Midfield | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1981 | Frank Tashman | Attack | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1981 | Bill Teresky | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 1982 | |||||
| 1982 | Rich Anderson | Midfield | Levittown Memorial | Nassau | NY |
| 1982 | James Bissell | Attack | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 1982 | Mark Brannigan | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1982 | Rhett Cavanaugh | Midfield | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 1982 | John Caveny | Attack | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1982 | John Detommaso | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1982 | Pat Doyle | Goal | Port WA | Nassau | NY |
| 1982 | Greg Erdley | Midfield | North Rockland | — | NY |
| 1982 | Tom Gunderson | Midfield | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1982 | Jim Koestner | Midfield | Mineola | Nassau | NY |
| 1982 | Tom Korrie | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1982 | Nick Lantuh | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1982 | Glenn Lay | Midfield | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 1982 | Jeff Lynch | Attack | Clarkstown South | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1982 | Gerard Marino | Attack | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 1982 | Brad McLam | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 1982 | Mark Moore | Attack | Horseheads | — | NY |
| 1982 | Steve Paletta | Defense | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 1982 | Guy Riccardi | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 1982 | Tom Romano | Defense | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1982 | Tom Rosa | Midfield | Rush-Henrietta | — | NY |
| 1982 | Chris Rosata | Attack | Waterloo | — | NY |
| 1982 | John Stefanini | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1982 | Bruce Yancy | Attack | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1983 | |||||
| 1983 | Doug Bradley | Attack | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 1983 | James Brandon | Attack | Hempstead High | — | NY |
| 1983 | Greg Cannella | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1983 | Ron Card | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1983 | Tom Carmean | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1983 | Bruce Chanenchuk | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1983 | Todd Curry | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1983 | Joe DeMocko | Attack | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 1983 | Pat Donahue | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1983 | Tom Engelke | Midfield | Sewanhaka | Floral Park | NY |
| 1983 | Brad Fish | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1983 | Chris Hein | Attack | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1983 | Rob Jaffee | Defense | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1983 | Joe Mahecha | Midfield | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1983 | Gordie Maples | Attack | Rush-Henrietta | — | NY |
| 1983 | Marty McCormick | Goal | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1983 | Dave Nelson | Attack | Hempstead High | — | NY |
| 1983 | Jason Reese | Goal | West Babylon | Suffolk | NY |
| 1983 | Dave Schwartzberg | Defense | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1983 | Rich Winkoff | Attack | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 1984 | |||||
| 1984 | Jim Bardwell | Attack | Tully | Central | NY |
| 1984 | Mark Bellanca | Attack | Sweet Home | Buffalo | NY |
| 1984 | Tim Bracken | Attack | Nyack | — | NY |
| 1984 | Brian Caragher | Attack | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1984 | John Cunniffe | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 1984 | Bill Gahan | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1984 | Chris Garvey | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1984 | J.J. Gildea | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1984 | Frank Marropodi | Midfield | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1984 | Edwin McGowen | Attack | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 1984 | Tim McIntee | Midfield | East Islip | — | NY |
| 1984 | Jim McNamara | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1984 | Pete McSherry | Defense | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1984 | Craig Mygatt | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 1984 | Adam Puritz | Attack | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1984 | Mike Romano | Defense | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1984 | Alan Rotatar | Midfield | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1984 | Joe Rzempoluch | Midfield | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1984 | Frank Scialdone | Goal | Rush-Henrietta | — | NY |
| 1984 | Robert Shupler | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1984 | Mark Stuver | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 1984 | Andy Vogt | Attack | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 1984 | Phil Willard | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1984 | John Zulberti | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1985 | |||||
| 1985 | Steve Anderson | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 1985 | Mike Babock | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 1985 | Mike Baudo | Midfield | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1985 | Jim Cheeseman | Goal | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1985 | Jose Colon | Midfield | Jamaica | — | NY |
| 1985 | Bill Coons | Attack | Rush-Henrietta | — | NY |
| 1985 | Jim Detommasso | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1985 | Dave Dunlap | Defense | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1985 | Jim Egan | Attack | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1985 | Chris Galgano | Attack | Great Neck South | — | NY |
| 1985 | Barry Greenberg | Defense | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1985 | Lee Halftown | Attack | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 1985 | Robert Hollister | Goal | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1985 | Steve Huff | Midfield | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1985 | Jeff Ihm | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1985 | Quint Kessenich | Goal | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1985 | Sal Locascio | Goal | Lindenhurst | Suffolk | NY |
| 1985 | Mack Martin | Goal | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 1985 | Jeff McNeill | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1985 | Scott Reh | Midfield | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY |
| 1985 | Dave Roberts | Midfield | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY |
| 1985 | Paul Scoafani | Attack | Portledge School | NY Metro | NY |
| 1985 | Tom Wenzle | Defense | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1985 | Phil Willard | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1985 | Steve Young | Attack | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 1985 | John Zulberti | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1986 | |||||
| 1986 | Dave Bonnist | Midfield | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1986 | R.P. Carlson | Attack | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 1986 | Scott Cox | Midfield | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 1986 | Josh Dennis | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1986 | Brian Foresta | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1986 | Geoff Hall | Attack | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1986 | Quint Kessenich | Goal | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1986 | Stuart Liebleim | Attack | Port WA | Nassau | NY |
| 1986 | Jacques Monte | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 1986 | Mike Nicolosi | Defense | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 1986 | Mike Parentis | Defense | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 1986 | Dennis Proulx | Defense | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1986 | Jonathon Reese | Attack | West Babylon | Suffolk | NY |
| 1986 | Mike Schattner | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1986 | Peter Schwasnick | Defense | Oceanside | Nassau | NY |
| 1986 | Mike Smith | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1986 | Tim Soudan | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 1986 | Mike Taranto | Defense | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1986 | Richard Tuohey | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1986 | G. Zecca. | Goal | Friends Academy | Locust Valley | NY |
| 1987 | |||||
| 1987 | Joe Barra | Midfield | Harborfields High | — | NY |
| 1987 | Scott Burnam | Midfield | Henninger High | Central | NY |
| 1987 | Paul Cannon | Midfield | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1987 | Chris Conforti | Attack | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1987 | Tim Corcoran | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1987 | Gerry DeLorenzo | Goal | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1987 | DeWitt Dominick | Attack | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1987 | Rich Franz | Attack | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 1987 | Ted Kellerman | Goal | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1987 | Matt Kelley | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 1987 | Mike Koldan | Goal | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1987 | Bill Kurisko | Midfield | Nanuet | — | NY |
| 1987 | Pat McCabe | Defense | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1987 | Phil McCarathy | Attack | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 1987 | Matt Moore | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1987 | Mike Morrissey | Attack | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 1987 | Jim Naslonski | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1987 | Dennis Nealon | Attack | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1987 | Steve Randby | Goal | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1987 | Dave Russell | Attack | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 1987 | Mike Schnattenr | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1987 | Jim Tepper | Defense | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1987 | Dave Tongglen | Midfield | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1987 | Robert Wurzburger | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1988 | |||||
| 1988 | Mike Acee | Attack | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1988 | Fred Amaya | Midfield | Hicksville | Nassau | NY |
| 1988 | Joe Bedell | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1988 | Matt Candel | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1988 | Tim Cox | Attack | Rush-Henrietta | — | NY |
| 1988 | Dan Donnelly | Midfield | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1988 | Tom Fuhrman | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 1988 | T.J. Geraci | Midfield | Sweet Home | Buffalo | NY |
| 1988 | Dan Johnson | Defense | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1988 | Marty Kelly | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 1988 | Darris Kilgour | Midfield | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 1988 | Cort Kim | Attack | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 1988 | Darren Lowe | Attack | Mineola | Nassau | NY |
| 1988 | Bruce May | Goal | Horseheads | — | NY |
| 1988 | Jim Naslonski | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1988 | John Rose | Midfield | MacArthur | Nassau | NY |
| 1988 | Jon Schoenweitz | Midfield | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1988 | Tim Shea | Goal | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1988 | Jim Strub | Midfield | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1988 | Ray Suris | Goal | Harborfields High | — | NY |
| 1988 | Jeff Tramboni | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1988 | Brian Tully | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1988 | Dave Willard | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1988 | Blake Wynot | Midfield | Friends Academy | Locust Valley | NY |
| 1989 | |||||
| 1989 | Chris Affolter | Defense | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1989 | Jamie Archer | Attack | Nottingham | Central | NY |
| 1989 | Kevin Barry | Goal | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1989 | Paul Cantabene | Midfield | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1989 | Dave Chaney | Attack | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 1989 | Liam Daly | Midfield | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1989 | Dave Donatello | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1989 | Mike Drab | Midfield | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1989 | Alex Francois | Attack | Jamaica | — | NY |
| 1989 | Mario Guaglianone | Attack | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1989 | Jeff King | Midfield | Cortland | Central | NY |
| 1989 | Chris Kowalski | Attack | Sweet Home | Buffalo | NY |
| 1989 | Mike Levine | Attack | Horace Greeley | — | NY |
| 1989 | Mike Mahoney | Attack | St. Lawrence Central | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 1989 | Mike Mangino | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1989 | Torr Marro | Midfield | Paul Schreiber | — | NY |
| 1989 | Scott McMahon | Attack | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 1989 | Steve McMahon | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1989 | Jim Murry | Goal | Oceanside | Nassau | NY |
| 1989 | Tom Naglieri | Attack | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1989 | Tom Peters | Midfield | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 1989 | Matt Riter | Midfield | Homer Central | Central | NY |
| 1989 | Andy Seal | Defense | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1989 | Chad Snopek | Midfield | Horseheads | — | NY |
| 1989 | Tom Stamos | Attack | Friends Academy | Locust Valley | NY |
| 1989 | Jeff Tomaso | Midfield | Colonie | Albany | NY |
| 1989 | Chuck Twoguns | Midfield | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 1990 | |||||
| 1990 | Rick Aguilar | Goal | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1990 | Ric Beardsley | Defense | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1990 | Sam Cady | Defense | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1990 | Charles Cirigliano | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 1990 | Bill Duffy | Attack | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1990 | Peter Fahey | Midfield | Friends Academy | Locust Valley | NY |
| 1990 | Todd Higgins | Defense | Port WA | Nassau | NY |
| 1990 | Ian Hinchcliffe | Attack | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 1990 | Jeff Iserson | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 1990 | Christian Johns | Attack | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1990 | Charlie Lochwood | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1990 | Kevin Lowe | Attack | Mineola | Nassau | NY |
| 1990 | Ron Lytel | Midfield | Sweet Home | Buffalo | NY |
| 1990 | Richard Mastunduno | Midfield | Oceanside | Nassau | NY |
| 1990 | Andy McDonald | Goal | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 1990 | Mike McGovern | Defense | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 1990 | Paul Murphy | Midfield | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 1990 | Gary Nelson | Midfield | Elmont Memorial HS | — | NY |
| 1990 | Chris Nentwich | Midfield | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 1990 | Anthony Newman | Defense | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 1990 | Anthony Pavone | Attack | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 1990 | Brian Piccola | Attack | Oceanside | Nassau | NY |
| 1990 | Dave Schneid | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1990 | Jeff Schuessler | Midfield | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1990 | Adam Thompson | Midfield | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 1990 | Brian Tomeo | Midfield | Port WA | Nassau | NY |
| 1990 | Mfon Udo | Attack | Jamaica | — | NY |
| 1990 | Nick Van Remortel | Attack | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1990 | Gavin Wynot | Attack | Friends Academy | Locust Valley | NY |
| 1990 | Eric Zelko | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1991 | |||||
| 1991 | Ric Beardsley | Defense | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1991 | Mike Bordi | Attack | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1991 | Peter Burnett | Attack | Jamaica | — | NY |
| 1991 | Scott Conklin | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1991 | Anthony DiMarzo | Attack | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1991 | Mark Fietta | Midfield | Jordan-Elbridge | Central | NY |
| 1991 | James Gaensbauer | Midfield | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1991 | Mike Grasso | Attack | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 1991 | Joe Guglielmo | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1991 | Todd Higgins | Defense | Paul Schreiber | — | NY |
| 1991 | E. J. Youngling | Attack | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1991 | Peter Jacobs | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1991 | Andy Joyce | Attack | Henninger High | Central | NY |
| 1991 | Dennis Kelly | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1991 | Tom LoPresti | Goal | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 1991 | Jim Morrissey | Attack | Skaneateles | Central | NY |
| 1991 | Christopher Onderdonk | Midfield | Green Meadow Waldorf | — | NY |
| 1991 | Anthony Pavone | Attack | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 1991 | Gary Reh | Attack | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY |
| 1991 | Chris Remington | Attack | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 1991 | Chad St. Hilaire | Midfield | St. Lawrence Central | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 1991 | Jack Sullivan | Midfield | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 1991 | Mike Todd | Goal | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1991 | Ryan Weis | Attack | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 1992 | |||||
| 1992 | Brian Bacso | Midfield | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1992 | Justin Boyd | Defense | Horace Greeley | — | NY |
| 1992 | Jason Buttles | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1992 | Louis Demopulos | Defense | Jamaica | — | NY |
| 1992 | Brian Duffy | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1992 | Mike Eckert | Attack | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 1992 | John Gagliardi | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1992 | Todd Kearney | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1992 | Todd Kelleher | Defense | Horseheads | — | NY |
| 1992 | Mike Larocco | Goal | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 1992 | Jon Marcus | Goal | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1992 | Brian McNally | Attack | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 1992 | Alfredo Meola | Defense | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1992 | Jim Morrissey | Midfield | Trinity Pawling | New England Western | NY |
| 1992 | Pritesh Patel | Goal | Jamaica | — | NY |
| 1992 | Mark Phillips | Attack | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1992 | Gary Reh | Attack | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY |
| 1992 | Jason Sececa | Midfield | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 1992 | Tommy Smith | Defense | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1992 | Scott Sullivan | Midfield | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY |
| 1992 | Harry Taylor | Defense | Portledge School | NY Metro | NY |
| 1992 | Eric Triolo | Defense | Walt Whitman | — | NY |
| 1992 | Brett VeRost | Midfield | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY |
| 1992 | Andrew Whipple | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1993 | |||||
| 1993 | Scott Allen | Attack | Chenango Forks | Southern Tier/Port Crane | NY |
| 1993 | Joe Brock | Attack | Islip | — | NY |
| 1993 | Mike Fahey | Defense | Friends Academy | Locust Valley | NY |
| 1993 | Charlie Fischer | Midfield | Saratoga Springs | Albany | NY |
| 1993 | Brett Frood | Midfield | Jordan-Elbridge | Central | NY |
| 1993 | Guillermo Garcia | Goal | Croton-Harmon | — | NY |
| 1993 | Andy Godfrey | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1993 | Rich Grismer | Goal | Kellenberg Memorial | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1993 | Robert Healy | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1993 | Craig Katz | Attack | Mepham High | Nassau | NY |
| 1993 | Rob Lyng | Goal | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1993 | Darren Mahoney | Defense | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1993 | Judd Newkirk | Midfield | LaSalle Institute | Albany/Troy | NY |
| 1993 | Jason Osier | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1993 | Marc Pechaitis | Attack | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 1993 | Anthony Picone | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1993 | Mike Polack | Defense | MacArthur | Nassau | NY |
| 1993 | Andy Rodriguez | Midfield | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 1993 | Brent Rothfuss | Midfield | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 1993 | Tommy Smith | Defense | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1993 | Mark Spruyt | Goal | East Islip | — | NY |
| 1993 | Anthony Tufano | Goal | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1993 | Merrill Turnbull | Attack | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1993 | Craig Van Tine | Attack | St. Francis Prep | Buffalo | NY |
| 1993 | John Warner | Midfield | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 1993 | Joe Whaley | Defense | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1993 | Andrew Whipple | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1993 | Shawn Yerkes | Defense | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 1994 | |||||
| 1994 | Ryan Adams | Midfield | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 1994 | Tom Alexander | Defense | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 1994 | Spencer Baugher | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1994 | Lou Bevilacqua | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1994 | Sean Bowler | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1994 | Jeff Burke | Attack | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 1994 | Phil Chesler | Defense | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 1994 | Christian Cook | Midfield | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1994 | Mike Delpercio | Midfield | Hicksville | Nassau | NY |
| 1994 | Dan Denihan | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1994 | Dean Falzon | Midfield | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 1994 | Mike Fenzel | Midfield | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1994 | Thomas Fitzpatrick | Midfield | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 1994 | Dennis Foley | Attack | Colonie | Albany | NY |
| 1994 | Kevin Geberth | Midfield | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1994 | Chris Georgalas | Attack | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 1994 | Andrew Godfrey | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1994 | Bobby Healy | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 1994 | Al Hernandez | Defense | Walt Whitman | — | NY |
| 1994 | Jon Hess | Attack | Nyack | — | NY |
| 1994 | Brendan Higgins | Midfield | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 1994 | John Hutt | Midfield | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY |
| 1994 | Scott James Alberi | Midfield | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 1994 | John Kasselakis | Goal | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1994 | David King | Midfield | Cortland | Central | NY |
| 1994 | John Luisi | Midfield | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 1994 | Christopher Masotto | Midfield | Portledge School | NY Metro | NY |
| 1994 | John Nolan | Midfield | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 1994 | Tim O Shea | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1994 | Matt OKelly | Midfield | St. Mary's School | — | NY |
| 1994 | Greg Peters | Attack | Horace Greeley | — | NY |
| 1994 | Eric Petranchuk | Midfield | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 1994 | Brian Price | Midfield | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1994 | Brock Riffel | Attack | Sweet Home | Buffalo | NY |
| 1994 | Dan Shea | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1994 | Marc Sullivan | Midfield | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 1994 | Bob Toner | Attack | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 1994 | Jeffrey VanDaley | Midfield | Monsignor Farrell | NY Metro | NY |
| 1994 | Keith Wemple | Attack | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 1994 | Mark Whaling | Midfield | Horace Greeley | — | NY |
| 1994 | Mike Zoanetti | Goal | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1995 | |||||
| 1995 | Jason Allacco | Midfield | Monsignor Farrell | NY Metro | NY |
| 1995 | Seamus Brophy | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 1995 | Sean Carney | Attack | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY |
| 1995 | Josh Cornick | Attack | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 1995 | Rick Darnley | Defense | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY |
| 1995 | Rich Degenfelder | Goal | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 1995 | Dan Denihan | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1995 | Brian Haggerty | Midfield | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 1995 | Casey Hard | Midfield | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 1995 | Kevin Healy | Goal | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 1995 | Zach Hergott | Defense | East Meadow | — | NY |
| 1995 | Jay Jalbert | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 1995 | Scott Jankow | Attack | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 1995 | Kevin Lavey | Attack | Harborfields High | — | NY |
| 1995 | Mike Leahy | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 1995 | Jeff Lowe | Midfield | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 1995 | Thomas Maxwell | Midfield | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 1995 | Duncan Miller | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 1995 | Robbie Mulligan | Goal | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 1995 | Damon Oliver | Midfield | LaSalle Institute | Albany/Troy | NY |
| 1995 | Chris Schiller | Midfield | McQuaid Jesuit | Monroe County | NY |
| 1995 | Matt Schroeder | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 1995 | Eric Sopracasa | Midfield | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 1996 | |||||
| 1996 | Billy Armstrong | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 1996 | Roger Buttles | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 1996 | Will Campbell | Sachem | Suffolk | NY | |
| 1996 | Tim Cocks | Northport | Suffolk | NY | |
| 1996 | Kevin DeWall | Waterloo | — | NY | |
| 1996 | Chad Donnelly | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 1996 | Shawn Felix | St. Lawrence Central | St. Lawrence | NY | |
| 1996 | Jared Frood | Jordan-Elbridge | Central | NY | |
| 1996 | Paul Grassi | Mt. St. Michael's | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1996 | Jason Hard | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY | |
| 1996 | Chris Harned | Sachem | Suffolk | NY | |
| 1996 | Jason Heinze | Paul Schreiber | — | NY | |
| 1996 | Brian Jabalon | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY | |
| 1996 | Jay Jalbert | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 1996 | Ryan Kamerdin | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY | |
| 1996 | Bryan Kuck | Long Island Lutheran | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1996 | Chris Lynch | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY | |
| 1996 | Dan Mathewson | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 1996 | Dan Newman | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 1996 | Chris Packard | Harborfields High | — | NY | |
| 1996 | Greg Papa | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 1996 | Jim Reichert | Smithtown | Suffolk | NY | |
| 1996 | Ken Yanicky | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY | |
| 1997 | |||||
| 1997 | Joe Barile | Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy | Nassau | NY | |
| 1997 | Eric Burns | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 1997 | John Burns | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY | |
| 1997 | Brian Dalton | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY | |
| 1997 | P.J. DiConza | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 1997 | Chris Gabrielli | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 1997 | Tom Galavin | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1997 | Jeremy Guski | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 1997 | Greg Horowitz | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY | |
| 1997 | Paul Koechler | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1997 | Justin Kohlbrenner | Henninger High | Central | NY | |
| 1997 | Jason Lavey | Harborfields High | — | NY | |
| 1997 | Don Little | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY | |
| 1997 | Cliff Lorenzo | Waldorf | — | NY | |
| 1997 | Marc Morley | Hugh Williams Senior High | Canton | NY | |
| 1997 | Jason Motta | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY | |
| 1997 | Shawn Nadelen | Rush-Henrietta | — | NY | |
| 1997 | Dan Newman | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 1997 | Dave Perlman | Oswego | — | NY | |
| 1997 | Christian Pforr | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 1997 | Jason Pohlman | St. Francis Prep | Buffalo | NY | |
| 1997 | Dough Shanahan | Sachem | Suffolk | NY | |
| 1997 | Eric Wedin | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY | |
| 1997 | Robert Wilcox | Poly Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1998 | |||||
| 1998 | Nick Ballou | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY | |
| 1998 | Dan Chemotti | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 1998 | Josh Coffman | — | — | NY | |
| 1998 | Chad DeBolt | Waterloo | — | NY | |
| 1998 | Will Driscoll | Fairport | Monroe County | NY | |
| 1998 | Mike Ferrari | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 1998 | Guilian Gary | Horseheads | — | NY | |
| 1998 | Gunnar Goettelmann | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 1998 | Christian Gould | Waldorf | — | NY | |
| 1998 | Dave Haddeland | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 1998 | Tom Hardy | Tully | Central | NY | |
| 1998 | Scott Harvey | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 1998 | Dave Hunter | East Syracuse-Minoa | Central | NY | |
| 1998 | Jason Kahn | Northport | Suffolk | NY | |
| 1998 | Tom Kessler | Midfield | Hicksville | Nassau | NY |
| 1998 | Jeff Kinsella | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY | |
| 1998 | Paul Koechler | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1998 | Steve Kowalik | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY | |
| 1998 | Ryan McClay | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 1998 | Mike Mollot | Sachem | Suffolk | NY | |
| 1998 | Mark Morley | Hugh Williams Senior High | Canton | NY | |
| 1998 | Nick Murtha | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 1998 | Nick Polanco | Oceanside | Nassau | NY | |
| 1998 | Erik Refvik | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 1998 | P.J. Rosecrans | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 1998 | Rob Scipioni | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 1998 | Brandon Seneca | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY | |
| 1998 | Al Tofani | Liverpool | Central | NY | |
| 1998 | Bryan Walker | Hicksville | Nassau | NY | |
| 1999 | |||||
| 1999 | Will Bodine | Portledge School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1999 | Kevin Brennan | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 1999 | Greg Conklin | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 1999 | Andy Copeland | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY | |
| 1999 | Adam Doneger | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY | |
| 1999 | Jason Doneger | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY | |
| 1999 | Julian Gould | Nyack | — | NY | |
| 1999 | Ryan Harris | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 1999 | Michael Howley | Wantagh | Nassau | NY | |
| 1999 | Michael Hughes | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY | |
| 1999 | Sean Lackaye | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1999 | Sean Lindsay | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY | |
| 1999 | Jason Mauro | Sachem | Suffolk | NY | |
| 1999 | Ryan McClay | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 1999 | Raweras Mitchell | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY | |
| 1999 | Josh Molinari | Oswego | — | NY | |
| 1999 | Adam Neary | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 1999 | J. P. Schalk | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY | |
| 1999 | Mark Perry | Portledge School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1999 | John Ryan | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY | |
| 1999 | Tim Sachs | Riverdale Country School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 1999 | Anthony Scaglione | Harborfields High | — | NY | |
| 1999 | Don Scott | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 1999 | John Stickl | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY | |
| 1999 | Brian Zuchelli | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 2000 | |||||
| 2000 | Andrew Agoliati | Poughkeepsie | New England Western | NY | |
| 2000 | Nick Allegretti | Penfield | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2000 | Steve Brundage | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 2000 | Jeff Bryan | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2000 | Bryan Campo | Smithtown | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2000 | Nick Culotti | Guilderland | Albany | NY | |
| 2000 | Tim DeBlois | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY | |
| 2000 | Jason Donegar | Hewlett | Nassau | NY | |
| 2000 | Kevin Foster | Massena | St. Lawrence | NY | |
| 2000 | Alex Fountain | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY | |
| 2000 | Alex Foutain | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY | |
| 2000 | Spencer Gellman | Horace Mann | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2000 | Corey Harned | Holbrook Sachem | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2000 | Andrew Huelskoetter | St. John the Baptist | Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 2000 | Jeremy Kyrkostas | Hicksville | Nassau | NY | |
| 2000 | Mike Levin | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2000 | Sean Lindsay | Cortlandt Manor | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2000 | Steve Lykudis | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 2000 | Michael Martino | Long Island Lutheran | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2000 | Joe McDermott | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY | |
| 2000 | Sean McGowan | Glens Falls | Albany | NY | |
| 2000 | Chris Mucciolo | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2000 | Ryan Neward | Williamsville East | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2000 | David Pavlik | Chenango Forks | Southern Tier/Port Crane | NY | |
| 2000 | Steven Piacente | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2000 | Dave Pittard | Skaneateles | Central | NY | |
| 2000 | Jesse Sorensen | Long Island Lutheran | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2000 | Adam Swyers | St. John the Baptist | Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 2000 | Tim White | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY | |
| 2001 | |||||
| 2001 | Chris Cara | Patchogue Medford | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2001 | Kevin Cepelak | Northport | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2001 | Bryan Cinque | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY | |
| 2001 | Luke D'Aquino | Attack | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 2001 | Matt Danowski | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 2001 | Luke Daquino | Sachem | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2001 | Stephen Devoe | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2001 | Andrew Eisen | Midwood | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2001 | Matt Ellement | Midfield | Queensbury | Albany | NY |
| 2001 | Matthew Ellement | Queensbury | Albany | NY | |
| 2001 | Mike Felber | Defense | McQuaid Jesuit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2001 | Mike Fieber | McQuaid Jesuit | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2001 | Kyle Georgalas | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2001 | Pete Grecco | Attack | St. Francis Prep | Buffalo | NY |
| 2001 | Pete Greco | St. Francis Prep | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2001 | Derek Howells | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2001 | Derick Howells | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2001 | Jon Kane | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY | |
| 2001 | Kevin Langtry | Massapequa | Nassau | NY | |
| 2001 | Tyler Nugent | Seepinac | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2001 | Greg Peyser | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 2001 | Jake Plunket | Homer Central | Central | NY | |
| 2001 | Pat Reiley | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 2001 | Pat Reilly | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2001 | Bill Schell | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2001 | Brandon Spillet | Liverpool | Central | NY | |
| 2001 | Brandon Spillett | Attack | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 2001 | Casey Stevenson | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2001 | Chris Stock | Penfield | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2001 | Pat Walsh | Wantagh | Nassau | NY | |
| 2001 | Joe Yevoli | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 2002 | |||||
| 2002 | Mike Abbott | Nottingham | Central | NY | |
| 2002 | Bryan Adams | Guilderland | Albany | NY | |
| 2002 | Joe Boulukos | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 2002 | Steve Byrnes | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2002 | Bret Caresky | Northport | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2002 | Bret Caretsky | Attack | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2002 | Matt Cassalia | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 2002 | Robert Christy | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2002 | Greg Cohen | Syosset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2002 | Jon Conners | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY | |
| 2002 | Matt Danowski | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 2002 | Kyle Dowd | Northport | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2002 | Ben Gliklich | Horace Mann | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2002 | Pete Grecco | Attack | St. Francis Prep | Buffalo | NY |
| 2002 | Pete Greco | St. Francis Prep | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2002 | Bob Gross | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 2002 | Ryan Lewis | East Syracuse-Minoa | Central | NY | |
| 2002 | Danny Loftus | Syosset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2002 | Pat Meade | Schenectady | Albany | NY | |
| 2002 | Alex Muro | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY | |
| 2002 | Kieran Murphy | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2002 | Dan Nolan | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2002 | Steven Panarelli | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 2002 | Greg Peyser | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 2002 | Eric Pittard | Skaneateles | Central | NY | |
| 2002 | Jordan Rabidou | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2002 | Chris Renzi | Fairport | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2002 | Greg Rommel | Henninger High | Central | NY | |
| 2002 | Kevin Rutledge | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2002 | K.J. Sauer | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY | |
| 2002 | Chip Schmidt | West Islip | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2002 | Ryan Schoenig | Sachem | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2002 | Dennis Smith | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2002 | Rob Smith | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2002 | Drew Thompson | Northport | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2002 | Lewi Two | Guns | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 2002 | Lewi Two Guns | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2002 | Chris Understein | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2002 | Chris Unterstein | Attack/Midfield | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2002 | Pat Walsh | Wantagh | Nassau | NY | |
| 2002 | Joe Walters | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2002 | Matt Zash | Massapequa | Nassau | NY | |
| 2003 | |||||
| 2003 | Russel Altman | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2003 | Josh Ayrassian | Hugh Williams Senior High | Canton | NY | |
| 2003 | Tony Ballard | Whitney Point | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2003 | Victor Barger | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY | |
| 2003 | Mike Blocho | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2003 | Mike Bocklet | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY | |
| 2003 | Jesse Brundige | Portledge School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2003 | Kieran Carney | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY | |
| 2003 | Matt Cassalia | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 2003 | Andrew Clayton | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2003 | Brian Clayton | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2003 | Greg Cohen | Syosset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2003 | Gregory Cohen | Attack | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2003 | Preston Connell | West Islip | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2003 | Drew Dabrowski | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 2003 | Matt Danowski | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 2003 | Jonathan Engelke | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 2003 | Tony Ferreira | Midfield | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2003 | Tony Ferriera | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2003 | Steve Giannone | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY | |
| 2003 | Peter Glass | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY | |
| 2003 | Kyle Guadagnolo | Jordan-Elbridge | Central | NY | |
| 2003 | Chris Hahm | Saratoga Springs | Albany | NY | |
| 2003 | Terence Higgins | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY | |
| 2003 | Steve Hoffman | LaSalle Institute | Albany/Troy | NY | |
| 2003 | Mark Johnson | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2003 | Casey Lewis | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY | |
| 2003 | B.J. Linder | Attack | Webster Schroeder | Monroe County | NY |
| 2003 | Ben Loefke | Iroquois | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2003 | Dan Loftus | Goalie | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2003 | Danny Loftus | Syosset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2003 | Mike MacDonald | Henninger High | Central | NY | |
| 2003 | Adam Mahfouda | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY | |
| 2003 | Steve Panarelli | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2003 | Steven Panarelli | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 2003 | Michael Piacente | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2003 | Will Presti | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY | |
| 2003 | Jordan Rabidou | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2003 | Mike Rimmer | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2003 | Nate Seigal | Riverdale Country School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2003 | Ricky Smith | Hicksville | Nassau | NY | |
| 2003 | Drew Thompson | Northport | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2003 | Peter Trombino | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 2003 | Mark Warner | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2004 | |||||
| 2004 | Steve Amman | Putnam Valley | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2004 | Steve Ammann | Midfield | Putnam Valley | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2004 | Steve Babbles | Skaneateles | Central | NY | |
| 2004 | Mike Blocho | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2004 | Nick Brown | Riverdale Country School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2004 | Mark Bryan | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2004 | John Carrozz | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY | |
| 2004 | John Carrozza | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2004 | Don Clay | Penfield | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2004 | Peter Coluccini | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY | |
| 2004 | Chris Corteau | West Seneca West | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2004 | James Davis | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY | |
| 2004 | Anthony Dugan | James I. O'Neill | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY | |
| 2004 | Chris Finn | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2004 | Sean Flanagan | Hugh Williams Senior High | Canton | NY | |
| 2004 | Dan Galasso | West Islip | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2004 | Steve Giannone | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY | |
| 2004 | John Glynn | Lindenhurst | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2004 | Chris Greenman | Nottingham | Central | NY | |
| 2004 | Andrew Hanover | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 2004 | Adam Hyde | West Seneca East | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2004 | R. J. Lamontagne | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2004 | Shane Koppens | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY | |
| 2004 | R.J. Lamontagne | Midfield | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2004 | Kent Lucas | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY | |
| 2004 | Max Mauro | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY | |
| 2004 | Craig McDonald | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY | |
| 2004 | Andrew Miller | William Floyd | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2004 | Greg Niewieroski | Watertown | Central | NY | |
| 2004 | David Pastenak | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2004 | David Pasternak | Attack | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2004 | Rory Pedrick | Saratoga Springs | Albany | NY | |
| 2004 | Carlos Pena | Mt. St. Michael's | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2004 | Chris Peyser | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2004 | Stephen Peyser | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 2004 | Scott Rodgers | MacArthur | Nassau | NY | |
| 2004 | Stefan Schroeder | East Syracuse-Minoa | Central | NY | |
| 2004 | Max Seibald | Hewlett | Nassau | NY | |
| 2004 | Ben Stein | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2004 | Craig Stevenson | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2004 | Jeff Strittmatter | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2004 | Tony Tanzi | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2004 | Nick Tintle | MacArthur | Nassau | NY | |
| 2004 | Kevin Unterstein | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2004 | Zach Widbin | Clarkstown South | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2005 | |||||
| 2005 | Matt Abbott | Nottingham | Central | NY | |
| 2005 | Joe Assante | Pine Bush | Mid-Hudson | NY | |
| 2005 | Jake Boyce | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2005 | Mark Bryan | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2005 | Mark Cizenski | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 2005 | Brandon Corp | Chittenango | Central | NY | |
| 2005 | Basil Daratsos | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2005 | Tom Davis | Division Avenue | Nassau/Levittown | NY | |
| 2005 | Kyle Flanagan | Hugh Williams Senior High | Canton | NY | |
| 2005 | Noah Fossner | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2005 | Adam Ghitelman | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 2005 | Steve Giannone | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY | |
| 2005 | Dave Grossman | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2005 | Dan Hardy | Tully | Central | NY | |
| 2005 | Nick Hautau | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY | |
| 2005 | Josh Jones | James I. O'Neill | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY | |
| 2005 | Mike Karwoski | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 2005 | Bob McAuley | Hicksville | Nassau | NY | |
| 2005 | Jon McMahon | Sweet Home | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2005 | Andrew Miller | William Floyd | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2005 | Cullen Molinari | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2005 | Kenny Nims | Watertown | Central | NY | |
| 2005 | Pat Perritt | Sachem East | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2005 | Gavin Petracc | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2005 | Gavin Petracca | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2005 | Matt Petre | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2005 | Chris Peyser | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2005 | Matt Pietroforte | Poly Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2005 | Chris Ritchie | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2005 | Scott Rodgers | MacArthur | Nassau | NY | |
| 2005 | Jon Schneider | Massapequa | Nassau | NY | |
| 2005 | Patrick Schram | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2005 | Patrick Schramm | Defense | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2005 | Max Seibal | Hewlett | Nassau | NY | |
| 2005 | Max Seibald | Midfield | Hewlett | Nassau | NY |
| 2005 | Matt Sullivan | West Islip | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2005 | Mike Thon | Penfield | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2005 | Austin Walker | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2005 | Alex Weber | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY | |
| 2005 | Brian Welch | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2006 | |||||
| 2006 | Pat Arlantico | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY | |
| 2006 | Pat Arlantico | A | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY |
| 2006 | Ryder Bohlander | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY | |
| 2006 | Bobbie Bosco | Midfield | Hendrick Hudson | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2006 | Bobbie Bosco | M | Hendrick Hudson | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2006 | Robbie Bosco | Hendrick Hudson | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2006 | Sean Burk | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2006 | Sean Burk | M | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2006 | Sean Burke | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 2006 | Mike Camarado | Guilderland | Albany | NY | |
| 2006 | Mike Camarado | M | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2006 | Keith Clancy | Pine Bush | Mid-Hudson | NY | |
| 2006 | Keith Clancy | A | Pine Bush | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2006 | Dylan D'Alessio | D | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2006 | Dylan D'Alessio | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 2006 | Chris Daniello | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY | |
| 2006 | Jesse Demase | Owego Free Academy | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2006 | Kyle DeVito | D | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2006 | Kyle DeVito | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2006 | Brendon Donovan | St. Jude | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2006 | Craig Dowd | Northport | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2006 | Craig Dowd | A | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2006 | Kevin Federico | A | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2006 | Kevin Federico | West Islip | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2006 | Kyle Felix | St. Lawrence Central | St. Lawrence | NY | |
| 2006 | Kyle Felix | A | St. Lawrence Central | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 2006 | Noah Fossner | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2006 | Noah Fossner | G | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2006 | Adam Ghitelman | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 2006 | Adam Ghitelman | G | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2006 | Mickey Haight | M | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2006 | Mickey Haight | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2006 | Daniel Halayko | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2006 | Daniel Halayko | D | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2006 | Bobby Hayes | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY | |
| 2006 | Bobby Hayes | M | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2006 | Woody Johnson | M | Poly Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2006 | Woody Johnson | Poly Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2006 | Ryan Lowe | M | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2006 | Ryan Lowe | Fairport | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2006 | Chris Lubin | Syosset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2006 | Chris Lubin | A | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2006 | Sean Lucas | A | Oceanside | Nassau | NY |
| 2006 | Sean Lucas | Oceanside | Nassau | NY | |
| 2006 | Nick Martell | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2006 | Nick Martell | M | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2006 | Kelly McKenna | Penfield | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2006 | Kelly McKenna | M | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2006 | Joe Messina | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2006 | Joe Messina | D | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2006 | Rickey Mirabito | Attack | Chenango Forks | Southern Tier/Port Crane | NY |
| 2006 | Rickey Mirabito | A | Chenango Forks | Southern Tier/Port Crane | NY |
| 2006 | Ricky Mirabito | Chenango Forks | Southern Tier/Port Crane | NY | |
| 2006 | Mike Novosel | G | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2006 | Mike Novosel | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2006 | Garrett O'Neil | St. Jude | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2006 | Danny Orlando | G | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2006 | Danny Orlando | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY | |
| 2006 | Chris Parker | Midwood | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2006 | Chris Parker | A | Midwood | NY Metro | NY |
| 2006 | Chris Rirchie | Attack | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2006 | Chris Rirchie | A | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2006 | Christian Scuderi | West Islip | Suffolk | NY | |
| 2006 | Christian Scuderi | D | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2006 | David Shield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY | |
| 2006 | David Shield | LSM | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2006 | Trever Sipperly | Midfield | Greenwich | Albany | NY |
| 2006 | Trevor Sipperly | Greenwich | Albany | NY | |
| 2006 | Conner Sweeney | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY | |
| 2006 | Brett Vecchio | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY | |
| 2006 | Brett Vecchio | M | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2006 | Adam Vogl | St. Jude | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2006 | Jaren Woeppel | West Genesee | Central | NY | |
| 2006 | Jaren Woppel | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2006 | Jaren Woppel | D | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2006 | Nick Zaleski | D | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2007 | |||||
| 2007 | Greg Bensman | LSM | West Seneca East | Buffalo | NY |
| 2007 | Greg Bensman | LSM | West Seneca East | Buffalo | NY |
| 2007 | Chris Bocklet | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2007 | Ryder Bohlander | Defense | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2007 | Robbie Bosco | Midfield | Hendrick Hudson | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2007 | Michael Brockway | Poly Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2007 | Michael Brockway | Goalie | Poly Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2007 | Mike Camardo | Guilderland | Albany | NY | |
| 2007 | Mike Camardo | Guilderland | Albany | NY | |
| 2007 | Grant Catalino | A | Webster Schroeder | Monroe County | NY |
| 2007 | Grant Catalino | Attack | Webster Schroeder | Monroe County | NY |
| 2007 | Jeff Cohen | Attack | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2007 | Jeff Cohen | A | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2007 | Andrew Collins | Midfield | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY |
| 2007 | Steven DeNapoli | Midfield | Hewlett | Nassau | NY |
| 2007 | Steven DeNapoli | M | Hewlett | Nassau | NY |
| 2007 | Phil Dimin | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2007 | Phil Dimin | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2007 | Nick DiSarro | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2007 | Nick DiSarro | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2007 | Brian Douglass | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2007 | Kyle Flanagan | Attack | Hugh Williams Senior High | Canton | NY |
| 2007 | Ryan Flanagan | D | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2007 | Ryan Flanagan | Defense | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2007 | John Galloway | Goalie | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2007 | John Galloway | G | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2007 | Adam Ghitelman | Goalie | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2007 | Adam Ghitelman | G | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2007 | Anthony Greco | Defense | St. Francis Prep | Buffalo | NY |
| 2007 | Tom Guadagnolo | Defense | Jordan-Elbridge | Central | NY |
| 2007 | Tom Guadagnolo | D | Jordan-Elbridge | Central | NY |
| 2007 | Ryan Hantverk | M | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2007 | Ryan Hantverk | Midfield | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2007 | Tim Henderson | Defense | Tully | Central | NY |
| 2007 | Tim Henderson | D | Tully | Central | NY |
| 2007 | Matthew Hull | A | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2007 | Matthew Hull | Attack | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2007 | Ryan Ivory | Saratoga Springs | Albany | NY | |
| 2007 | Ryan Ivory | Midfield | Saratoga Springs | Albany | NY |
| 2007 | David Lau | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2007 | David Lau | A | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2007 | Jay Lucas | Attack | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 2007 | Jay Lucas | A/M | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 2007 | Robert McCabe | Midwood | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2007 | Robert McCabe | Midwood | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2007 | Tim McCormack | G | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 2007 | Tim McCormack | Goalie | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 2007 | Matt Misisco | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2007 | Matt Misisco | Midfield | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2007 | Tyler Morse | Attack | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2007 | Tyler Morse | A | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2007 | Zach Nash | G | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2007 | Zach Nash | Goalie | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2007 | Rob Pannell | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2007 | Rob Pannell | M | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2007 | Kevin Piegare | D | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2007 | Kevin Piegare | Defense | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2007 | Elijha Printup | A | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 2007 | Elijha Printup | Attack | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 2007 | Scott Raffensperger | Defense | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2007 | Scott Raffensperger | Guilderland | Albany | NY | |
| 2007 | Mark Reel | A | Union Endicott | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2007 | Mark Reel | Attack | Union Endicott | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2007 | Tom Rynn | M | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2007 | Tom Rynn | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2007 | T.J. Smith | Defense | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2007 | T.J. Smith | D | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2007 | Kevin Stoeckel | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2007 | Tom Szevin | Midfield | James I. O'Neill | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY |
| 2007 | Tom Szevin | M | James I. O'Neill | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY |
| 2007 | Mike Teeter | Attack | Trinity Pawling | New England Western | NY |
| 2007 | Mike Teeter | A | Trinity Pawling | New England Western | NY |
| 2007 | Justin Turri | M | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2007 | Justin Turri | Midfield | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2007 | Joel White | M | Cortland | Central | NY |
| 2007 | Joel White | Midfield | Cortland | Central | NY |
| 2007 | Mike White | M | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 2007 | Mike White | Midfield | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 2007 | Ryan Young | A | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2007 | Ryan Young | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2008 | |||||
| 2008 | Wilford Alexander | Midfield | Midwood | NY Metro | NY |
| 2008 | Wilfred Alexander | Midfield | Midwood | NY Metro | NY |
| 2008 | Justin Annunziato | Defense | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY |
| 2008 | Chris Bocklet | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2008 | Sam Bradman | Midfield | Hugh Williams Senior High | Canton | NY |
| 2008 | Michael Brockway | Goalie | Poly Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2008 | Jeff Cohen | Attack | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2008 | Drew Coholan | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2008 | Luke Cometti | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2008 | John Conneely | Attack | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2008 | Drew Cook | Attack | Valley Central | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2008 | Steve Damario | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2008 | Balso Del | Midfield/FO | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2008 | Alex DelBalso | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2008 | Mike DeNapoli | Midfield | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2008 | Daniel DiMaria | Defense | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2008 | Jack Doherty | Attack | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2008 | Kevin Drew | Midfield | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2008 | Connor English | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2008 | Nick Galasso | Attack | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2008 | Kevin Gordon | Midfield | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2008 | Tyler Granelli | Attack/Midfield | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2008 | David Hamlin | Defense | New Hartford | Central | NY |
| 2008 | Travis Harrington | Midfield | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2008 | Stephen Ianzito | Midfield | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 2008 | Adam Ismaeil | Midfield | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2008 | Anthony Krizman | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2008 | John Lawless | Goalie | St. Francis Prep | Buffalo | NY |
| 2008 | Aaron Lupo | Midfield | Schenectady | Albany | NY |
| 2008 | Dan McKinney | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2008 | Chris Moffa | Goalie | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2008 | Joe Morasco | Attack | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2008 | D.J. O'Connell | Midfield | Colonie | Albany | NY |
| 2008 | Michael O'Hagen | Midfield | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2008 | Nick O'Reilly | Attack | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2008 | Keenan Ochwat | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2008 | Thomas Palasek | Attack | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY |
| 2008 | Paul Pate | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2008 | Dan Pezzola | Midfield | Union Endicott | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2008 | Daniel Pezzolla | Midfield | Union Endicott | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2008 | Elijah Printup | Midfield | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 2008 | Emmett Printup | Attack | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 2008 | Connor Rice | Attack | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2008 | Tim Rommel | Midfield | Henninger High | Central | NY |
| 2008 | Forrest Schonnfeld | Attack | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2008 | Forrest Sonnenfeldt | Attack | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2008 | Tony Spada | Midfield | Saugerties | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2008 | Nick Trizano | Attack | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2008 | Max Weisenberg | Midfield | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 2008 | Greg Wright | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2009 | |||||
| 2009 | Steve Abba | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2009 | Steve Abba | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2009 | Pierce Adams | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2009 | Pierce Adams | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2009 | Robert Bellairs | Plainedge | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Robert Bellairs | Plainedge | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Ian Braddish | Midfield | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2009 | Ian Brames | St. Mary's School | — | NY | |
| 2009 | Bradley Cappellini | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Bradley Cappellini | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | James Cathers | Midfield | Corcoran | Central - Syracuse | NY |
| 2009 | Drew Coholon | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2009 | Prince Del | Midfield | Frontier Senior High | Buffalo/Hamburg | NY |
| 2009 | Clay Delprince | Frontier Senior High | Buffalo/Hamburg | NY | |
| 2009 | Dave DiMaria | Attack | Half Hollow Hills West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2009 | John Duvnjak | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | John Duvnjak | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Connor English | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Connor English | Manhasset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | John Fennessy | — | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2009 | A.J. Fiore | — | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2009 | Andrew Fiore | New Dorp | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | Ethan Fox | — | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2009 | Jared Franze | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2009 | Jared Franze | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2009 | Jeff Froccaro | Port WA | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Nick Galasso | Attack | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2009 | Zac Guy | Midfield | Tully | Central | NY |
| 2009 | Luke Haggerty | — | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2009 | Kevin Interlicchio | — | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2009 | Corey Johnson | Valley Central | Mid-Hudson | NY | |
| 2009 | Thomas Keith | Syosset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Thomas Keith | Syosset | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Aaron Lee | Portledge School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | Aaron Lee | Portledge School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | Nick Longo | Goalie | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2009 | Zach Losco | Midfield | Hauppaugue | Suffolk | NY |
| 2009 | Joey Lustgarten | Attack | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2009 | Steve Mahle | Goalie | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2009 | Joe Marasco | — | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2009 | Michael McCormack | Defense | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2009 | Dan McKinney | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2009 | Dan McKinney | Niskayuna | Albany | NY | |
| 2009 | Chris Moffa | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | Chris Moffa | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | Ethan Murphy | West Seneca East | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2009 | Ethan Murphy | West Seneca East | Buffalo | NY | |
| 2009 | Steven Murphy | Midfield | William Floyd | Suffolk | NY |
| 2009 | Luke Murray | Pine Bush | Mid-Hudson | NY | |
| 2009 | Julian Musikantz | Riverdale Country School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | Rory Nunamacher | Guilderland | Albany | NY | |
| 2009 | Rory Nunamacher | Guilderland | Albany | NY | |
| 2009 | Nick O'Reilly | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY | |
| 2009 | Nick O'Reilly | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY | |
| 2009 | Tyler Perrelle | — | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2009 | Mike Poppleton | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2009 | Matt Pratt | — | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2009 | John Ranagan | — | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2009 | Austin Rose | — | Southern Tier | NY | |
| 2009 | Brendan Saylor | Fairport | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2009 | Schreiber | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 2009 | Thomas Schreiber | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2009 | Thomas Schreiber | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY | |
| 2009 | Forrest Sonnefeldt | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | Forrest Sonnefeldt | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | Tony Spada | Saugerties | Mid-Hudson | NY | |
| 2009 | Will Stewart | — | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2009 | Ben Strauss | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Ben Strauss | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY | |
| 2009 | Matt Taylor | Attack | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2009 | Ty Thompson | Attack | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 2009 | Nick Trizano | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | Nick Trizano | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY | |
| 2009 | de Veerdonk Van | Midfield | Putnam Valley | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2009 | Thof Van | Midfield | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2009 | Jimmy van de VeerdonPutnam Valley | — | Hudson Valley | NY | |
| 2009 | Kyle Van Thof | Penfield | Monroe County | NY | |
| 2010 | |||||
| 2010 | Ryan Alden | LSM | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2010 | Ryan Alden | LSM | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2010 | Daniel Alles | Defense | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2010 | Daniel Alles | Defense | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2010 | Drew Belinsky | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Drew Belinsky | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | John Brandofino | Attack | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2010 | John Brandofino | Attack | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2010 | Tyler Brooks-Lambert | Midfield | Midlakes | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 2010 | Tyler Brooks-Lambert | Midfield | Midlakes | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 2010 | Brian Buglione | Defense | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2010 | Brian Buglione | Defense | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2010 | James Cathers | Midfield | Corcoran | Central - Syracuse | NY |
| 2010 | James Cathers | Midfield | Corcoran | Central - Syracuse | NY |
| 2010 | Eric Chadderdon | Defense | — | Buffalo | NY |
| 2010 | Eddie Collins | Goalie | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Eddie Collins | Goalie | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Kevin Collins | Midfield | — | Buffalo | NY |
| 2010 | Zack Connors | Attack | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2010 | Greg Cove | Defense | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2010 | Greg Cove | Defense | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2010 | Mike Daniello | Attack | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2010 | Thomas DeNapoli | Midfield | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Thomas DeNapoli | Midfield | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Joe Dupra | Defense | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2010 | Joe Dupra | Defense | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2010 | Robert Duvnjak | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Robert Duvnjak | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Andy Fazio | Defense | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY |
| 2010 | Ryan Feuerstein | Midfield | — | Buffalo | NY |
| 2010 | Christopher Fiore | Goalie | New Dorp | NY Metro | NY |
| 2010 | Christopher Fiore | Goalie | New Dorp | NY Metro | NY |
| 2010 | Ryan Fitzgerald | Attack | Putnam Valley | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2010 | Ryan Fitzgerald | Attack | Putnam Valley | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2010 | Joe Fletcher | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2010 | Joe Fletcher | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2010 | Matt Fox | Attack | Horace Mann | NY Metro | NY |
| 2010 | Kevin Freeman | Midfield | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2010 | Kevin Freeman | Midfield | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2010 | Nick Galasso | Attack | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Nick Galasso | Attack | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | John Glesener | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2010 | John Glesener | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2010 | Mike Grace | Goalie | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2010 | Mike Grace | Goalie | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2010 | Kyle Henry | Attack | — | Buffalo | NY |
| 2010 | Andrew Hodgson | Midfield | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Andrew Hodgson | Midfield | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Shawn Honovich | Midfield | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY |
| 2010 | Jack Keenan | Midfield | St. Lawrence Central | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 2010 | Jack Keenan | Midfield | St. Lawrence Central | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 2010 | Jack Keenan | Midfield | St. Lawrence Central | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 2010 | Ryan Kommer | Attack | Newark | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 2010 | James Lang | Defense | Hicksville | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | James Lang | Defense | Hicksville | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Jay Livermore | Defense | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2010 | Jay Livermore | Defense | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2010 | Zach Losco | Midfield | Hauppaugue | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Zachary Losco | Midfield | Hauppaugue | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Brandon Mangan | Attack | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Brandon Mangan | Attack | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Kieran McArdle | Attack | Connetquot | Suffolk County | NY |
| 2010 | Kieran McArdle | Attack | Connetquot | Suffolk County | NY |
| 2010 | Daniel McQuillan | Goalie | Kellenberg Memorial | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2010 | Daniel Mellynchuck | Midfield | Sayville | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Daniel Mellynchuck | Midfield | Sayville | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Dan Mellynchuk | Midfield | Sayville | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Maxx Meyer | Defense | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Maxx Meyer | Defense | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2010 | Mike O'Neil | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2010 | Mike O'Neil | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2010 | Joseph Ostrander | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Joseph Ostrander | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2010 | Mark Panneton | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2010 | Mark Panneton | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2010 | Jameson Pickel | Defense | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2010 | George Proechel | Attack | Lakeland | Yorktown Heights | NY |
| 2010 | Conor Prunty | Midfield | Walter Panas | Hudson Valley/Lakeland | NY |
| 2010 | Byron Quinn | Attack | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2010 | Byron Quinn | Attack | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2010 | Will Rotatori | Attack | Lakeland | Yorktown Heights | NY |
| 2010 | Brendan Saylor | Attack | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2010 | Brendan Saylor | Attack | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2010 | Thomas Schreiber | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2010 | Thomas Schreiber | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2010 | Bobby Sincero | Goalie | Hendrick Hudson | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2010 | Bobby Sincero | Goalie | Hendrick Hudson | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2010 | Torin Varn | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2010 | Torin Varn | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2010 | David Vaughan | Midfield | Lakeland | Yorktown Heights | NY |
| 2010 | Andrew Wagner | Defense | — | Buffalo | NY |
| 2010 | Bob Wardwell | Goalie | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2010 | Bob Wardwell | Goalie | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2010 | Mike Warner | Defense | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 2010 | Mike Warner | Defense | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 2010 | Jesse Wood | Attack | Seton Catholic | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2010 | Jesse Wood | Attack | Seton Catholic | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2010 | Carl Zimmerman | Midfield | Homer Central | Central | NY |
| 2010 | Artur Zych | Attack | Midwood | NY Metro | NY |
| 2010 | Artur Zych | Attack | Midwood | NY Metro | NY |
| 2011 | |||||
| 2011 | Zych Artur | Attack | Midwood | NY Metro | NY |
| 2011 | Andreycak Ben | Attack | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2011 | Wardwell Bob | Goalie | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2011 | Gamblin Brandon | Midfield | Sachem | Suffolk | NY |
| 2011 | Moriarity Chris | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2011 | Smith Chris | Midfield | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2011 | Fiore Christopher | Goalie | New Dorp | NY Metro | NY |
| 2011 | Prunty Conor | Midfield | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2011 | Hanson Drew | Attack | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2011 | Hays Drew | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2011 | Donahue Dylan | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2011 | Schurr Eddie | Defense | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2011 | Morelli Frank | Goalie | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2011 | Gambitsky Jake | Goalie | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2011 | Schof Jake | Midfield | Pine Bush | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2011 | Weil Jake | Midfield | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2011 | Burke James | Midfield | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2011 | Pannell James | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2011 | Bucci Joe | Midfield | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2011 | Leonard Joe | Attack | Hicksville | Nassau | NY |
| 2011 | Ostrander Joseph | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2011 | Rice Kevin | Attack | Skaneateles | Central | NY |
| 2011 | Keenan Kyle | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2011 | Pellegrino Mike | Defense | Connetquot | Suffolk County | NY |
| 2011 | Hamamoto Neil | Midfield/Attack | Riverdale Country School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2011 | Doktor Nick | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2011 | Schuler Nikhon | Defense | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2011 | Lasda Riley | Midfield | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2011 | Enright Rob | Defense | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2011 | Caffrey Robert | Attack | Lakeland High | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2011 | Duvnjak Robert | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2011 | Tuttle Sal | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2011 | Oakes Seth | Attack | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 2011 | Basile Stefan | Goalie | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2011 | Foley T.J. | Midfield | Mahopac | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2011 | Sanders T.J. | Attack | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2011 | Coll Tim | Attack | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2011 | Cox Tim | Midfield | Schenectady | Albany | NY |
| 2011 | Rotanz Tim | Attack | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2011 | Oliveri Zach | Goalie | Connetquot | Suffolk County | NY |
| 2012 | |||||
| 2012 | Dimillo Adam | Midfield | Timon St Jude | West Seneca | NY |
| 2012 | Fiore Adam | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2012 | Kris Alleyne | Goalie | Clarkstown South | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2012 | Ben Andreycak | Attack | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Hope Austin | Midfield | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 2012 | Tim Barber | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2012 | Andreycak Ben | Attack | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Riordan Blaze | Goalie | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Duvnjak Bobby | Defense/LSM | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Lott Brad | Midfield/FO | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Donnellan Brandon | Defense | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2012 | Hickey Brandon | Midfield | Harvey School | Pearl River | NY |
| 2012 | Barren Brenden | Defense | West Seneca West | Buffalo | NY |
| 2012 | Trevor Brosco | Midfield | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2012 | Harrington Chase | Defense/LSM | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2012 | Monteferante Chris | Midfield | Lakeland | Yorktown Heights | NY |
| 2012 | Fiore Christopher | Goalie | New Dorp | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Killion Cole | Defense/LSM | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Russell Connor | Midfield | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Parke Corey | Midfield | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Kenneth Coughlin | Attack | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Day Dalston | Attack | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 2012 | Muller Daniel | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Dalston Day | Attack | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 2012 | Derek DeJoe | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | DeJoe Derek | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Nick Doktor | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Brandon Donnellan | Defense | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2012 | Sean Doyle | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2012 | Bobby Duvnjk | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Sabovic Emin | Midfield | Christopher Columbus | NY | NY |
| 2012 | Shane Fee | Attack | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Ryan Feit | Goalie | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Christopher Fiore | Goalie | New Dorp | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Luke Goldstock | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2012 | Miller Gunnar | Midfield | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Brandon Hickey | Midfield | Harvey School | Pearl River | NY |
| 2012 | Austin Hope | Midfield | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 2012 | Kelly Jack | Goalie | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2012 | Lambert Jack | Defense | John Jay HS | Hudson Valley/Cross River | NY |
| 2012 | Miller Jack | Midfield | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Froccaro Jake | Midfield | Port WA | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Pannell James | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2012 | Michael Jenkins | Attack | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2012 | Sessa Joe | Attack | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2012 | Jack Kelly | Goalie | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2012 | Coughlin Kenneth | Attack | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | McNally Kevin | Midfield | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2012 | Schurr Kevin | Defense | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2012 | Cole Killion | Defense/LSM | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Alleyne Kris | Goalie | Clarkstown South | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2012 | Matt Landis | Defense | Pelham | Pelham | NY |
| 2012 | Brad Lott | Midfield/FO | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Goldstock Luke | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2012 | Tanner MacIvor | Defense | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2012 | Balzano Matt | Midfield | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Landis Matt | Defense | Pelham | Pelham | NY |
| 2012 | Schattner Matt | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2012 | Schultz Matt | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2012 | Sexton Matt | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2012 | Kevin McNally | Midfield | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2012 | Jenkins Michael | Attack | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2012 | Gunnar Miller | Midfield | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Jack Miller | Midfield | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Quinn Moroney | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Daniel Muller | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Doktor Nick | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | James Pannell | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2012 | Ciferri Paolo | Midfield | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2012 | Corey Parke | Midfield | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Rob Penney | Midfield | Valley Central | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2012 | Moroney Quinn | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Blaze Riorden | Goalie | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Penney Rob | Midfield | Valley Central | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2012 | Tim Rotanz | Attack | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2012 | Connor Russell | Midfield | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2012 | Feit Ryan | Goalie | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2012 | Emin Sabovic | Midfield | Christopher Columbus | NY | NY |
| 2012 | TJ Sanders | Attack | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2012 | Matt Schattner | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2012 | Matt Schultz | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2012 | Kevin Schurr | Defense | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2012 | Doyle Sean | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2012 | Joe Sessa | Attack | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2012 | Matt Sexton | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2012 | Fee Shane | Attack | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2012 | Sanders T.J. | Attack | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2012 | MacIvor Tanner | Defense | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2012 | Barber Tim | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2012 | Rotanz Tim | Attack | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2012 | Brosco Trevor | Midfield | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2013 | |||||
| 2013 | Auburn Adrian | Defense | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2013 | DiPasquale Albie | Attack | Pittsford Sutherland | Pittsford | NY |
| 2013 | Brooks Ben | Midfield | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2013 | Reevers Ben | Attack | Palmyra Macedon | Macedon | NY |
| 2013 | Balkam Brian | Goalie | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2013 | Rogers Brian | Midfield | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2013 | Cummins Charlie | Defense | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2013 | Marino Dominic | Midfield | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY |
| 2013 | Lasda Eli | Midfield | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2013 | Henderson Jadeon | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2013 | Levins Jake | Attack | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2013 | Schneider Jake | Attack | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2013 | Vakiener Jay | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2013 | Sessa Joe | Attack | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2013 | Vaughn Kevin | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2013 | Maloney Lucas | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2013 | Goldstock Luke | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2013 | Kaser Matt | Attack | Spencerport | Spencerport | NY |
| 2013 | D'Amario Mike | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2013 | Aponte Nick | Midfield | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2013 | Reilly Peter | Defense | Christian Bros Academy | Niskayuna | NY |
| 2013 | Keenan Ryan | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2013 | Cosens Tanner | Goalie | ME-Endwell | Endwell | NY |
| 2013 | Rotanz Timothy | Attack | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2013 | Sirico Zach | Attack | Sayville | Suffolk | NY |
| 2014 | |||||
| 2014 | Alexander Becerra | Defense | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2014 | Craig Berge | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2014 | Eddie Bouhall | Defense | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2014 | Alex Bronzo | Defense | Putnam Valley | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2014 | Brian Cannon | Attack | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2014 | Pat Carlin | Midfield | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2014 | Tim Cousin | Midfield | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2014 | Mike D'Amario | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2014 | Joe Delasho | Midfield | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2014 | Nicholas Demeo | Attack | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2014 | Tyler Dunn | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2014 | Eddie Eddinton | Midfield | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 2014 | Brennan Ferguson | Mid/Attack | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 2014 | Connor Filipowski | Defense | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2014 | Benjamin Fox | Attack | Horace Mann | NY Metro | NY |
| 2014 | Logan Greco | Defense | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2014 | Colin Greenway | Attack | Williamsville East | Buffalo | NY |
| 2014 | Joe Grossi | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2014 | Tim Hickey | Defense | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2014 | Ryan Keenan | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2014 | Justin Kesselering | Attack | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2014 | Jack Korzelius | Midfield | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2014 | Jackson Lienhart | Attack | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2014 | Kyle Marr | Attack | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2014 | Pat McCormick | Attack | Hicksville | Nassau | NY |
| 2014 | Bradley McKinney | Midfield | Watertown | Central | NY |
| 2014 | Nick Mellen | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2014 | Kiernan Mullins | Attack | Islip | — | NY |
| 2014 | Aidan O'Brien | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2014 | Jacob Pulver | Defense | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2014 | Justin Reh | Attack | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY |
| 2014 | Troy Reh | Defense | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY |
| 2014 | Will Sands | Attack | Friends Academy | Locust Valley | NY |
| 2014 | James Schnepf | Goalie | Schenectady | Albany | NY |
| 2014 | Joe Sessa | Attack | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2014 | Kason Tarbell | Midfield | Salmon River | St. Lawrence | NY |
| 2014 | Timothy Truesdale | Midfiled | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2014 | Jordan Walter | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2014 | Noah Weissmann | Goalie | Horace Greeley | — | NY |
| 2014 | Christian Zawadzki | Midfield | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | |||||
| 2015 | Samantha Apuzzo | M | West Babylon | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Gerard Arceri | Midfield | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Madeline Barcia | D | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Brandon Barker | Midfield | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2015 | Erin Barry | M | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Grace Beshlian | G | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Edie Bouhall | Defense | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Ryan Bray | Midfield | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Logan Brennan | M | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY |
| 2015 | Dan Bullis | Attack | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Charlotte Campbell | G | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2015 | Kaitlyn Cerasi | A | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Mikaila Cheeseman | G | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2015 | Alex Concannon | Attack | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Alyssa Conklin | D | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2015 | Keely Connors | M | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 2015 | Vanessa Constantino | M | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Caroline Crump | A/M | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY |
| 2015 | Kellen D'Alleva | A | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | John Daniggelis | Midfield | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Samantha DeBellis | A | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2015 | Matt DeLuca | Goalie | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Nicole DeMase | M | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2015 | Micheline Dinardo | G | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2015 | Meghan Duffy | M/A | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 2015 | Tyler Dunn | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Sean Eccles | Midfield | Corcoran | Central - Syracuse | NY |
| 2015 | Connor Filipowski | Defense | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2015 | Lindsay Gamer | M | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2015 | Dana Gisonno | A | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2015 | Rebecca Golderman | M | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Austin Graehler | Midfeld | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2015 | Hanna Haven | M | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 2015 | Jeremiah Hemme | LSM | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2015 | Austin Henningsen | Midfield | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Erin Kelly | M | Clarkstown South | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2015 | Willie Klan | Goalie | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2015 | Nicole Leska | G | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2015 | Tomasina Leska | A | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2015 | Nicole Levy | A | East Islip | — | NY |
| 2015 | Joe Licciardi | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2015 | Ashley Lynch | A | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2015 | Madison Maher | M | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 2015 | Kyle Martinsen | Middie | Williamsville East | Buffalo | NY |
| 2015 | Kasey Mitchell | A/M | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Adrian Nash | Midfield | Tully | Central | NY |
| 2015 | Jake Nelson | Attack | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2015 | Danielle Nicosia | D | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Aidan O'Brien | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Aidan O'Brien | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Tom O'Connor | Defense | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2015 | Dylan Pantalone | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Dylan Pantalone | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Baley Parrott | M | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2015 | John Pendergast | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Sydney Pirreca | M | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | John Prendergast | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Gordon Purdie | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Cara Quimby | M | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Claire Quinn | M | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2015 | Mary Rahal | M | Queensbury | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Christie Raymond | M | Queensbury | Albany | NY |
| 2015 | Jourdan Roemer | A | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2015 | Lindsey Ronbeck | A | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Gabby Rosenzweig | M | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2015 | Joe Sessa | Attack | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2015 | John Shea | Defense | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2015 | Nicole Sliwak | A/M | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Max Spann | Attack | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2015 | James Stenzel | Defense | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 2015 | Rocco Sutherland | Attack | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Noah Taylor | Midfield | Watertown | Central | NY |
| 2015 | Allen Thibodeau | LSM | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2015 | Ryan Tierney | Attack | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2015 | Cara Trombetta | M | Sachem East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2015 | Brian Willets | Attack | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2016 | |||||
| 2016 | Gerard Arceri | Midfield | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2016 | Erin Barry | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Grace Beshlian | Goalie | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Charlotte Campbell | Goalie | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2016 | Kaitlyn Cerasi | Attack | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Alyssa Conklin | Defense | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2016 | Jared Conners | Defense | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2016 | Ian Cook | Attack | Horseheads | — | NY |
| 2016 | Vanessa Costantino | Midfield | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2016 | Lucas Cotler | Midfield | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Riley Cox | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2016 | Matt DeLuca | Goalie | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Nick Depietro | Defense | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2016 | Connor DeSimone | Attack | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2016 | Micheline DiNardo | Goalie | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2016 | Marisa DiVietro | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2016 | Megan Duffy | Attack | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 2016 | Sam Duggan | Midfield | Skaneateles | Central | NY |
| 2016 | Alissa Franze | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2016 | Kerry Gerety | Midfield | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2016 | Chris Gray | Attack | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2016 | Elizabeth Halpin | Midfield | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2016 | Luke Hanson | Midfield | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2016 | Lindsay Hogan | Midfield | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 2016 | Maddie Howe | Midfield | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2016 | Brett Jennings | Midfield | Valley Central | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2016 | Brendan Johnson | Attack | White Plains | — | NY |
| 2016 | Jack Keogh | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Noah Knopf | LSM | Fieldston School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2016 | Zachary Kryza | Defense | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2016 | Nicole Leska | Goalie | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2016 | Joe LiCalzi | Defense | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2016 | Natalia Lynch | Midfield | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2016 | Matt Magnan | Midfield | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 2016 | Colin Malarchuk | Defense | Fordham Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2016 | Tom McPartland | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Alexa Meager | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2016 | Olivia Miles | Midfield | Watertown | Central | NY |
| 2016 | Maddie Miller | Attack/Mid | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2016 | Cullen Morgan | Midfield | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 2016 | Jared Nugent | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2016 | Macaire O'Keefe | Attack | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Christian Paley | Attack | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2016 | Gabrielle Rosenzweig | Midfield | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2016 | Olivia Rosenzweig | Attack | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2016 | Gino Settacasi | Defense/LSM | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2016 | Nicole Sliwak | Midfield | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Conor Smith | Attack | West Islip | Suffolk | NY |
| 2016 | Ryan Tierney | Attack | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2016 | Elizabeth Trojan | Suffern | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2016 | Ali Turner | Attack | Geneva | Finger Lakes | NY |
| 2016 | Hannah VanMiddelem | Goalie | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2016 | Vanessa Walters | Goalie | Waterloo | — | NY |
| 2016 | Catie Woodruff | Midfield | Skaneateles | Central | NY |
| 2017 | |||||
| 2017 | Mackenzie Baker | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2017 | Eamon Bollinger | Attack | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2017 | Mackenzie Bolt | Midfield | Tully | Central | NY |
| 2017 | Abigail Bosco | Midfield | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2017 | Molly Carter | Attack | Lynbrook | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Thomas Casuccio | Goalie | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2017 | JP Cerini | Goalie | Horace Mann | NY Metro | NY |
| 2017 | Aleya Corretjer | Midfield | North Rockland | — | NY |
| 2017 | Sabrina Cristodero | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2017 | Buck Daley | Defense | Lakeland | Yorktown Heights | NY |
| 2017 | Kaitlyn Daly | Midfield | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2017 | Connor DeSimone | Attack | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2017 | Michael Doxie | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2017 | Amanda Fedor | Midfield | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2017 | Carlos Forde | Attack | Minisink Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2017 | Kadi Futia | Attack | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2017 | Alexa Gentile | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Kerry Gerety | Midfield | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2017 | Jillian Girardi | Midfield | Watertown | Central | NY |
| 2017 | Megan Gordon | Midfield | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Chris Gray | Attack | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2017 | Lauren Gray | Midfield | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2017 | Dylan Guarnieri | Defense | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2017 | Tyler Hess | Long-Stick Middie | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2017 | Allison Iodice | Attack | Suffern | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2017 | Shannon Kavanagh | Midfield | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2017 | Hayley Kmack | Midfield | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2017 | Lukas Kott | Midfield | Lakeland | Yorktown Heights | NY |
| 2017 | Peter LaSalla | Midfield | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY |
| 2017 | Ian Laviano | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2017 | Matt Licciardi | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2017 | Johnny Loughlin | Midfield | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY |
| 2017 | Sean Lulley | Attack | Half Hollow Hills East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2017 | Kevin Mack | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Justin Malpica | Midfield | Long Island Lutheran | NY Metro | NY |
| 2017 | Alexandra Murphy | Midfield | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Brendan Nichtern | Attack | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Danny Ochs | Defense | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Christian Paley | Attack | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2017 | Mackenzie Porter | Goalie | Hendrick Hudson | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2017 | Jillie Quevedo | Midfield | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2017 | Lucas Quinn | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2017 | Sioban Rafferty | Midfield | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Dan Raftis | Defense | Oswego | — | NY |
| 2017 | Sarah Reznick | Goalie | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Evelyn Roberts | Midfield | St. Mary's School | — | NY |
| 2017 | Olivia Rosenzweig | Midfield | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2017 | Steve Schneider | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2017 | Peter Schwab | Midfield | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2017 | Kyla Sears | Attack | Skaneateles | Central | NY |
| 2017 | Maggee Sheridan | Midfield | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2017 | Laura Skrzypczyk | Attack | West Seneca East | Buffalo | NY |
| 2017 | Gibson Smith | Defense | Pelham | Pelham | NY |
| 2017 | Taylor Strough | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2017 | Anthony Tebbano | Goalie | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2017 | Sophia Triandafils | Midfield | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2017 | Carter Watson | Defense | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2018 | |||||
| 2018 | Edward Arnold | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Emma Arnold | Midfield | Palmyra Macedon | Macedon | NY |
| 2018 | Tom Baker | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2018 | Zack Belter | Defense | Niagara Wheatfield | Buffalo | NY |
| 2018 | Reese Burek | Attack | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2018 | Cassidy Burns | Midfield | Plainedge | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Emerson Cabrera | Midfield | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2018 | Conor Calderone | Midfield | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2018 | Olivia Carner | Midfield | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2018 | Morgan Cassiliana | Midfield | New Dorp | NY Metro | NY |
| 2018 | Thomas Casuccio | Goalie | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2018 | Tom Cecere | Attack | Grand Island | Buffalo | NY |
| 2018 | Amanda Cramer | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2018 | TaNia Cunningham | Defense | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 2018 | Kaitlyn Daly | Midfield | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2018 | Caroline DeBellis | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2018 | Sophia DeRosa | Midfield | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2018 | Katherine DeSimone | Attack | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2018 | Amanda Fedore | Midfield | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2018 | Maggie Fort | Midfield | Poly Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2018 | Elizabeth Fox | Midfield | North Rockland | — | NY |
| 2018 | Lindsey Frank | Midfield | Saratoga Springs | Albany | NY |
| 2018 | Jaclyn Gatti | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Grace Gavis | Midfield | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY |
| 2018 | Maren Geiger | Goalie | Nichols School | Buffalo | NY |
| 2018 | Kerri Gutenberger | Midfield | North Rockland | — | NY |
| 2018 | Tim Hegarty | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Cian Keohane | Attack | Harvey School | Pearl River | NY |
| 2018 | Griffin king | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2018 | Krissy Kowalski | Goalie | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Peter LaSalla | Midfield | Rocky Point | Suffolk | NY |
| 2018 | Nick LiCalzi | Long-Stick Middie | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2018 | Payton Lill | Midfield | Webster Schroeder | Monroe County | NY |
| 2018 | Claire Martell | Goalie | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2018 | Jessica Meneilly | Midfield | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 2018 | Michelle Messenger | Goalie | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2018 | Joshua Miller | Goalie | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2018 | James Morris | Defense | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2018 | Gianna New | Attack | Fox Lane | Hudson Valley/Bedford | NY |
| 2018 | Danny Ochs | Defense | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Angelo Petrakis | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Mackenzie Porter | Goalie | Hendrick Hudson | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2018 | Ethan Rall | Long-Stick Middie | Islip | — | NY |
| 2018 | Sarah Reznick | Goalie | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Meaghan Scutaro | Defense | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2018 | Katie Shanley | Attack | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2018 | Kiera Shanley | Midfield | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2018 | John Sidorski | Attack | East Islip | — | NY |
| 2018 | Rachel Spaulding | Attack | Queensbury | Albany | NY |
| 2018 | Ryan Sposito | Midfield | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2018 | Taylyn Stadler | Midfield | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Eoghan Sweeney | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2018 | Erin Tierney | Midfield | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Meaghan Tyrrell | Attack | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2018 | Alex Vardaro | Midfield | Hewlett | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Max Verch | Long-Stick Middie | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2018 | Katherine Wendell | Attack | Saratoga Springs | Albany | NY |
| 2018 | George Wichelns | Attack | Connetquot | Suffolk County | NY |
| 2018 | Kevin Winkoff | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2018 | Kyle Zawadzki | Attack | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2019 | |||||
| 2019 | Emma Arnold | Midfield | Palmyra Macedon | Macedon | NY |
| 2019 | Olivia Carner | Midfield | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2019 | Lexie Correia | Midfield | Long Beach | Nassau | NY |
| 2019 | Amelia Cunningham | Goalie | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2019 | Caroline DeBellis | Attack | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2019 | Kayla Downey | Midfield | West Babylon | Suffolk | NY |
| 2019 | Lindsey Frank | Midfield | Saratoga Springs | Albany | NY |
| 2019 | Kerri Gutenberger | Midfield | North Rockland | — | NY |
| 2019 | Kendall Halpern | Midfield | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2019 | Emma LoPinto | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2019 | Claire Martell | Goalie | Millbrook School | New England Western | NY |
| 2019 | Amanda Mavricos | Goalie | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2019 | Hailey McHenry | Attack | New Dorp | NY Metro | NY |
| 2019 | Caroline Mondiello | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2019 | Maddie Montgomery | Midfield | Queensbury | Albany | NY |
| 2019 | Ellie Mooney | Attack | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2019 | Amanda Nieman | Attack | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2019 | Danielle Pavinelli | Attack | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2019 | Morgan Schwab | Attack | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2019 | Aislinn Sweeney | Goalie | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2019 | Sophia Taglich | Defense | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2019 | Maria Themelis | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | |||||
| 2021 | Luca Accardo | Midfield | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | Brock Behrman | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2021 | Ryan Bell | Midfield | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2021 | Ryan Bell | Midfield | Smithtown West | Suffolk | NY |
| 2021 | Collin Bullock | Midfield | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2021 | Rory Connor | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | Harrison Cross | Attack | Pittsford Sutherland | Pittsford | NY |
| 2021 | Noah D'Andrea | Goalie | Christian Bros Academy | Niskayuna | NY |
| 2021 | Joe Diblasi | Defense | Oswego | — | NY |
| 2021 | Max Ettinghausen | Attack | McQuaid Jesuit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2021 | Nolan Firth | Defense | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 2021 | Jordan Gangaram | Long Stick Middie | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | Drew Godfrey | Attack | Trinity School | NY Metro | NY |
| 2021 | Matthew Graffeo | Goalie | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2021 | Will Hardy | Midfield | Tully | Central | NY |
| 2021 | Caleb Jacobson | Defense | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2021 | Collin Kuester | Goalie | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | Matt LaCombe | Goalie | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2021 | Devin Lefkowitz | Defense | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | Jared Lucich | Midfield | Christian Bros Academy | Niskayuna | NY |
| 2021 | Andrew McAdorey | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2021 | Connor Mesh | Midfield | Spencerport | Spencerport | NY |
| 2021 | Aidan Mulholland | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | Leo O'Brien | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2021 | Hunter Panzik | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | Matthew Perfetto | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | Patrick Pisano | Defense | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2021 | Lorenzo Ramos | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | John Schwarz | Midfield | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2021 | Joey Spallina | Attack | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2021 | Luke Stratton | Defense | Fayetteville-Manlius | Central | NY |
| 2021 | Jake Taylor | Attack | William Floyd | Suffolk | NY |
| 2021 | Joey Terrenzi | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2021 | Erik Vogt | Attack | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2021 | Greyson Vorgang | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2021 | Kevin Walter | Midfield | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2021 | Spencer Will | Goalie | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2021 | Jake Wilson | Defense | Shoreham-Wading River | Suffolk | NY |
| 2021 | Connor Winters | Goalie | McQuaid Jesuit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2022 | |||||
| 2022 | Luca Accardo | Midfield | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2022 | Colby Baldwin | Midfield | Scarsdale | — | NY |
| 2022 | Matthew Caputo | Attack | Long Island Lutheran | NY Metro | NY |
| 2022 | KJ Delane | Defense | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2022 | Noah Gibson | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2022 | Cal Girard | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2022 | Nick Hauman | Midfield | Webster Schroeder | Monroe County | NY |
| 2022 | Owen Kovacs | Attack | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2022 | Tyler Kuprianchik | Midfield | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2022 | Tyler Longo | Midfield | Kingston | Mid-Hudson/West Point | NY |
| 2022 | Scot Mackie | Attack | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2022 | Tyler McCarthy | Midfield | Connetquot | Suffolk County | NY |
| 2022 | Michael Meyer | Attack | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2022 | Quinn Nolan | Midfield | Palmyra Macedon | Macedon | NY |
| 2022 | Jesse Phelan | Defense | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2022 | Patrick Pisano | Defense | Cold Spring Harbor | Nassau County | NY |
| 2022 | Dylan Sageder | Long Stick Middie | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2022 | Joey Spallina | Attack | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2022 | Joey Terenzi | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2022 | Tommy Tyksinski | Attack | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2022 | Greyson Vorgang | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2022 | Caden Whaling | Midfield | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2023 | |||||
| 2023 | Colby Baldwin | Midfield | Scarsdale | — | NY |
| 2023 | Davey Carroll | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2023 | Liam Connor | Attack | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2023 | Owen Duffy | Attack | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2023 | Cal Girard | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2023 | Mikey Hayes | Midfield | West Seneca East | Buffalo | NY |
| 2023 | Michael Ippoliti | Goalie | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2023 | Francis Keneally | Long-Stick Middie | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2023 | Lucas Klokiw | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2023 | Andrew Lehrman | Goalie | Scarsdale | — | NY |
| 2023 | Jesse Lutz | Attack | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2023 | Kian McCarthy | Midfield | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2023 | Brendan O'Keefe | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2023 | Jack Peterson | Midfield | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2023 | Greyson Vorgasng | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2023 | Marshall Winkky-Wade | Defense | Horseheads | — | NY |
| 2024 | |||||
| 2024 | Michael Aiello | Attack | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2024 | Sammy Baek | Midfield | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2024 | Logan Banek | Midfield | New Hartford | Central | NY |
| 2024 | Nolan Bellotti | Midfield | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2024 | Jonah Carrier | Midfield | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2024 | Mason Carroll | Attack | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2024 | Isaac Cruz | Midfield | Pine Bush | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2024 | David Disque | Midfield | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2024 | Chris Iuliano | Defense | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2024 | Sean Kerwick | Midfield | Skaneateles | Central | NY |
| 2024 | Jesse Lutz | Attack | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2024 | Jake Martini | Midfield | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2024 | Tyler McDermott | Midfield | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2024 | Matthew McIntee | Midfield | East Islip | — | NY |
| 2024 | Braden McMahon | Attack | Vestal | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2024 | Michael Melkonian | Midfield | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2024 | Jack Mulholland | Defense | Manhasset | Nassau | NY |
| 2024 | Brendan O'Keefe | Attack | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2024 | Luke Osmanski | Defense | West Seneca East | Buffalo | NY |
| 2024 | Vincent Pantano | Attack | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2024 | Tim Plunkett | Attack | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2024 | Winter Rivera | Midfield | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 2024 | Owen Salanger | Goalie | Liverpool | Central | NY |
| 2024 | Spencer Spallone | Long-Stick Midfield | Midwood | NY Metro | NY |
| 2024 | Giancarlo Valenti | Defense | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2024 | Owen West | Midfield | South Side | Nassau/Rockville Centre | NY |
| 2024 | Jamison Wilders | Defense | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2024 | Tanner Williams | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2024 | Nathan Wolfe | Attack | Shenendehowa | Albany | NY |
| 2025 | |||||
| 2025 | Keegan Ahern | Long-Stick Midfield | Pittsford Sutherland | Pittsford | NY |
| 2025 | Jameson Blakeslee | Midfield | Horace Greeley | — | NY |
| 2025 | Matthew Byrne | Attack | Horace Greeley | — | NY |
| 2025 | Aidan Corbalis | Defense | Warwick Valley | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2025 | Matt Gianetti | Long-Stick Midfield | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2025 | Billy Haggerty | Attack | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2025 | Miguel Iglesias | Midfield | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2025 | Chris Iuliano | Defense | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2025 | Dillon Licht | Midfield | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2025 | Charlie Lockwood | Attack | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2025 | Matt Mayfield | Midfield | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2025 | Tyler McDermott | Midfield | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2025 | Gary Merril | Midfield | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2025 | Luke Mizro | Midfield | Skaneateles | Central | NY |
| 2025 | Mitchell Monte | Attack | Fairport | Monroe County | NY |
| 2025 | John Mooney | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2025 | Cooper Moore | Attack | Irondequoit | Monroe County | NY |
| 2025 | Luke Pasacreta | Midfield | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2025 | Tim Plunkett | Attack | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2025 | Connor Reynolds | Defense | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2025 | Winter Rivera | Attack | Gowanda | Buffalo | NY |
| 2025 | Spencer Spallone | Long-Stick Midfield | Midwood | NY Metro | NY |
| 2025 | Nico Spaziani | Midfield | Watertown | Central | NY |
| 2025 | Anthony Theodorakakos | Defense | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2026 | |||||
| 2026 | Boe Briggs | Midfield | Horseheads | — | NY |
| 2026 | Greyson Cabrera | Midfield | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2026 | Sami Chowdhrey | Attack | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2026 | Michael Communiello | Attack | Tottenville | NY Metro | NY |
| 2026 | Logan DeWaters | Defense | West Genesee | Central | NY |
| 2026 | Michael Galgano | Defense | Farmingdale | Nassau | NY |
| 2026 | Quentin Getzin | Midfield | Ithaca | Southern Tier | NY |
| 2026 | Dillon Gulotta | Long-Stick Midfield | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2026 | Billy Haggerty | Attack | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2026 | Cameron James | Attack | Smithtown East | Suffolk | NY |
| 2026 | Brodie Joyce | Attack | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2026 | Bret Kennedy | Defense | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2026 | Landon MacDougall | Attack | Saugerties | Mid-Hudson | NY |
| 2026 | Tommy Massaro | Midfield | Mount Sinai | Suffolk | NY |
| 2026 | Joseph Nicholson | Midfield | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2026 | Will Niejadlik | Attack | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2026 | Gavin O'Brien | Attack | Northport | Suffolk | NY |
| 2026 | Devin Paccione | Attack | Wantagh | Nassau | NY |
| 2026 | Tim Plunkett | Attack | Iona Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2026 | Connor Reynolds | Defense | Niskayuna | Albany | NY |
| 2026 | Daniel Rooney | Attack | St. Anthony's | Nassau/Suffolk Catholic | NY |
| 2026 | Spencer Spallone | Long-Stick Midfield | Poly Prep | NY Metro | NY |
| 2026 | Nigel Strazzini | Defense | Rye | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2026 | Adrian Sweeney | Midfield | Cicero-North Syracuse | Central/Syracuse | NY |
| 2026 | Anthony (AJ) Theodorakakos | Defense | Penfield | Monroe County | NY |
| 2026 | Avery Valenti | Midfield | Pittsford | Monroe County | NY |
| 2026 | Cameron Violante | Attack | Somers | Hudson Valley | NY |
| 2026 | Lee Warren | Attack | Guilderland | Albany | NY |
| 2026 | Brody Waxer | Attack | Syosset | Nassau | NY |
| 2026 | Nolan Wieczorek | Attack | Massapequa | Nassau | NY |